Wednesday 26 November 2008

Working Title Films and Film4

For Mrs Francis, we were told to use the structure, identified by Todorov ( Equilibrium, Disturbance and Resolution) to explore the following British Films in terms of narrative and structure:
Billy Elliot
Bridget Jones's Diary

The same applied to Film 4:
This is England
Brick Lane

Billy Elliot:
A young boy succeeds in his quest to become a ballet dancer.
Instead of going to Boxing lessons, he goes to ballet classes.
Father does not know
Ballet teacher notices his potential and tries to get him an audition at the Royal Ballet School.
The father disagrees when asked for permission, then re-considers.
At the end, it shows Billy aged 20, performing in Swan Lake.

Billy Elliot uses:
Equilibrium - we see Billy in his day to day life, hobbies and friends etc.
Disturbance - his dad does not agree with Ballet and there is a mining strike which his father is involved in, e.g. his dad is seen in a coach that is being thrown at with eggs.
Resolution - his son accepts that his son is good at ballet and at the end we see his dad come to watch Billy in Swan Lake.

Bridget Jones's Diary:
A detailed account of a 30 year old singly womans life on a hunt to find a husband.

Bridget Jones is an assistant at a London book publisher.
Feeling time pass her by, Daniel Cleaver, her boss starts flirting with her, she plunges straight in.
An affair ensues and she is head over heels.
She also keeps running into Mark Darcy, a barrister who has known her since a young child.
At the end, Bridget must make a decision, Daniel or Mark?

Bridget Jones's Diaet uses: 
Equilibrium - we see her in her day to day life, the narrative through her diary therefore we get a first hand account.
Disturbance - she is with Daniel who she then finds out is having an affair, therefore she has to deal with the break up.
Resolution - Bridget learns from her mistakes of bad men and chooses the more sensible option, Mark Darcy.

This is England:

Displays a young boys trauma of being brainwashed by the skinhead culture. Set in 1983.

Shaun is 12 and a bit of a loner, growing up with his mum in a grim costal town, his dad was killed fighting in the Falklands War.
On his way home from school, he runs into a group of skinheads, who against the expectations, turn out to be friendly and take him under their wing.
Soon, Shaun discovers parties, girls and snappy dressing, and finds some rold models in Woody, Milky and the rest of the gang.
Handling the complexities of masculinity, violence and race with sensitivity and lightness of touch.

This is England uses:
Equilibrium - showing his life and the culture of the skin heads.
Disturbance - the gang breaking up
Resolution - None

Brick Lane
Brick Lane is the story of Nazneen, a young Bangladeshi woman who is put into an arranged marriage with Chanu Ahmed.

A loveless marriage with the middle aged Chanu, she feels her soul is quietly dying.
Her sister Hasina, meanwhile, continues to live a carefree life back in Bangladesh.
Nazneen struggles to accept her lifestyle, until the hot headed young, Karim comes knocking at her door.
The novel ends with a surprise trip for Nazneen. Nazneen's daughters and Razia take her to an ice skating rink for the first time where she will be free to skate, even in her Sari.

Brick Lane uses:
Equilibrium - shows the life of a young Bangladeshi woman, and a typical life, e.g. arranged marriage.
Disturbance - Nazneen has to live with Chanu, but she has to survive in a whole new culture.
Resolution - they get the money.



1 comment:

Sacha van Straten said...

Hi Hannah,

I'm just wondering if we can say that there's a resolution in This Is England in terms of the message to the audience that being a racist doesn't pay? Or, that being a slave to the dynamics of the gang isn't fulfilling ultimately? I know this takes us out of the structure of Todorov's theory, as I'm proposing a resolution that addresses the relationship between director/scriptwriter and audience, rather than the resolution of the narrative structure itself; but it might just work? What do you think? I'll run it past Mrs F, as she's the theory queen of Berkhamsted!

See you tomorrow,

S